Characterization of three osteogenesis imperfecta collagen α 1(I) glycine to serine mutations demonstrating a position-dependent gradient of phenotypic severity

Type I collagen alpha 1(I) glycine to serine substitutions, resulting from G-to-A mutations, were defined in three cases of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The Gly substitutions displayed a gradient of phenotypic severity according to the location of the mutation in the collagen triple helix. The most C-terminal of these, Gly565 to Ser, led to the lethal perinatal (type II) form of OI, whereas the more N-terminal mutations, Gly415 and Gly352 to Ser, led to severe OI (type III/IV) and moderate OI (type IVB) respectively. These data support the notion that glycine substitutions towards the C-terminus of the alpha 1(I) or alpha 2(I) chains will be more clinically severe than those towards the N-terminus. This results from the more disruptive effect of the mutations at the C-terminus on helix initiation and C- and N-terminal helix directional propagation. This generalization must be modified by considering the nature of the glycine substitution and the surrounding amino acid sequence, since the helix is composed of subdomains of differing stability which will affect the ability of helix re-nucleation and propagation.